Lead providers
| Provider | Close rate | Leads/dealer/mo | Dealerships | Leads |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Capital One | 3.5% | 64 | 70 | 36,633 |
| Autotrader | 3.0% | 73 | 169 | 111,397 |
| Edmunds | 2.5% | 37 | 49 | 16,930 |
| CarGurus | 2.4% | 167 | 228 | 382,076 |
| CARFAX | 2.2% | 65 | 153 | 92,838 |
| Cars.com | 2.1% | 94 | 129 | 114,412 |
| OfferUp | 1.3% | 31 | 26 | 7,249 |
| TrueCar | 1.2% | 68 | 73 | 43,080 |
| 1.0% | 118 | 28 | 15,700 | |
| CarZing | 1.0% | 17 | 48 | 6,755 |
Leads from January 2026 to November 2026, counted as sold if they sold within 90 days. Green close rates beat the sample-wide average of 4.5%.
Head-to-head comparisons
Two providers compared inside the dealerships that run both, where the sales team is the same on both sides.
- CARFAX vs CarGurus · 90 stores
- Autotrader vs CarGurus · 80 stores
- CarGurus vs Cars.com · 73 stores
- CARFAX vs Cars.com · 57 stores
- Autotrader vs CARFAX · 55 stores
- Autotrader vs Cars.com · 48 stores
- CarGurus vs TrueCar · 38 stores
- Capital One vs CarGurus · 31 stores
- CARFAX vs TrueCar · 31 stores
- Cars.com vs TrueCar · 29 stores
- Capital One vs CARFAX · 26 stores
- Capital One vs Cars.com · 25 stores
- Autotrader vs TrueCar · 21 stores
- Autotrader vs Capital One · 19 stores
- Capital One vs TrueCar · 17 stores
- CarGurus vs Edmunds · 11 stores
For comparison: the dealership's own channels
No paid provider comes close to a customer who already knows the dealership.
| Channel | Close rate | Dealerships |
|---|---|---|
| Referral | 35.2% | 212 |
| Repeat customer | 34.4% | 211 |
| Walk-in | 27.9% | 250 |
| Phone | 12.6% | 234 |
Cite or embed this data
Free to use in articles, reports and presentations. Please credit AutoRaptor with a link to this page.